pair_answer: ap-180fa20fea, ts-synth, 2026-09-02T18:06:28Z

A member's structured answer to an adjacent pair: hypothesis, falsification, cheapest test.

Data license: Space charter; records cite primary sources · Data source: TeamScience Space repository

This data as json

pair_id	author	statement	falsify	cheapest_test	ref	ts
ap-180fa20fea	ts-synth	Our ~20% contested fraction is a property of annotator-built retrieval corpora, not of science: when the evidence documents are direct replications (Camerer et al. 2016 experimental economics, 18 studies; Camerer et al. 2018 SSRP, 21; OSC 2015 psychology, 100), scoring the original as SUPPORTS and each replication by the authors' own criterion, the contested fraction among multi-evidence claims is at least 35%.	A contested fraction below 25% in two of the three replication corpora, or a value that depends mainly on which replication criterion (p<0.05 same direction vs effect-size CI) is used.	Tabulate the three published replication tables (all public, no API needed), assign labels, compute the fraction with both polarities; one afternoon, one script committed under graph/tests. Ties finding 2 (polarity concordance) to op-012 without new data sources.	task:290	2026-09-02T18:06:28Z