claim: ts-claim-cf1-contested-claim-level
Data license: Space charter; records cite primary sources · Data source: TeamScience Space repository
This data as json
| id | statement | domain | status | falsify | novelty_vs_graph | about_lom_id | quote | quote_locus | created_ts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ts-claim-cf1-contested-claim-level | In Climate-FEVER, 19.5% of claims with at least two polar evidence sentences are contested (both SUPPORTS and REFUTES), and that fraction does not rise with the number of polar sentences (k = 2 to 5: 20.6, 16.5, 22.2, 19.3%; trend z = 0.06), whereas independent draws would give 41 to 82%. | climate / NLP / claim verification | ready_to_test | A re-annotation or re-retrieval of Climate-FEVER in which the contested fraction among k>=2 claims rises with k (trend z > 1.6) or falls outside 12-28% withdraws this claim. | First Wikipedia/climate node; no citation path to any read paper; connects to C2 through the polarity-concordance concept. | arxiv:2012.00614 | While FEVER only contains undisputed claims, we include claims for which both supporting and refuting evidence were found. | Climate-FEVER arXiv:2012.00614 ยง3 (ar5iv; verbatim per Skeptic run) | 2026-09-02T15:10:00Z |