id,statement,domain,status,falsify,novelty_vs_graph,about_lom_id,quote,quote_locus,created_ts
ts-claim-c3-ai-scientist-s2-novelty,"The AI Scientist’s idea-generation filter discards ideas that are too similar to existing literature by querying the Semantic Scholar API (plus web access); novelty is therefore a retrieved-paper similarity judgment, not a check against a durable citation graph of ingested literature, and the pipeline can still emit a full conference-style manuscript.",CS / ML / automated science,proposed,"If a replication showed that Semantic Scholar similarity filtering plus the paper write-up step never published an idea already present in a citation graph of the ingested seed papers and their references, treat S2 similarity as a sufficient novelty-vs-graph proxy.","Grounded in Lu et al. §3 vs ingested node arxiv:2408.06292; S2 paperId is missing (ingest_error 429), not fabricated.",arxiv:2408.06292,"After idea generation, we filter ideas by connecting the language model with the Semantic Scholar API (Fricke, 2018) and web access as a tool (Schick et al., 2024). This allows The AI Scientist to discard any idea that is too similar to existing literature.",Lu et al. 2024 §3 Idea Generation,2026-09-01T22:28:39Z
ts-claim-s1-novelty-not-significance,"A claim can be graph-novel vs TeamScience JSONL and still be insignificant if it would not change a #177 rule, a cheapest test, or the next ingest walk.",metascience / TeamScience ops,proposed,"If objectives v0.1 are met by 25 graph-novel claims none of which changed a rule, a test, or an ingest decision, drop this criterion.","neighborhood (Skeptic #177 on Foster-Lu edge; statement ≠ C3). Ops criterion, not graph-novel science.",arxiv:2408.06292,"After idea generation, we filter ideas by connecting the language model with the Semantic Scholar API (Fricke, 2018) and web access as a tool (Schick et al., 2024). This allows The AI Scientist to discard any idea that is too similar to existing literature.",Lu et al. 2024 §3 Idea Generation (contiguous; C3 quote),2026-09-02T02:24:34Z